The fair version — what each is great at, and where an all-in-one wins.
Harvest
Free tier
Time tracking built to get agencies paid
Teams $9/seat/mo (annual); timesheet approvals only on Enterprise at $14/seat/mo
Free: Free but limited to 1 seat and 2 projects
Genuinely great at
- Polished time-to-invoice flow with online payment collection
- Native QuickBooks and Xero integrations
- Well-regarded reporting and profitability tracking
Where Log My Business wins
- Timesheet approvals are free — Harvest gates them to its $14 Enterprise tier
- $7.99 unlimited vs per-seat pricing that scales with usage
- Also does mileage, CRM, tasks, and whiteboards — Harvest is time + invoicing only
- No 1-seat / 2-project free wall
Toggl Track
Free tier
Frictionless time tracking
Starter $9/user/mo; Premium $18/user/mo (approvals and profitability)
Free: Genuinely generous free plan for up to 5 users
Genuinely great at
- Best-in-class one-click tracking, autotracker, and idle detection
- 100+ integrations and a mature API
- Clean, flexible reporting and billable-rate analysis
Where Log My Business wins
- Approvals are free — Toggl puts them behind its $18 Premium plan
- A full business platform, not a pure tracker
- Time flows straight to invoices with no export/import
- $7.99 unlimited beats $18 Premium
Clockify
Free tier
Cheap time tracking at scale
Basic $3.99; Standard $5.49/user/mo (approval and lock require Standard+)
Free: Free for up to 5 users, with unlimited projects
Genuinely great at
- Very cheap paid tiers and broad platform coverage
- Unlimited projects on the free plan
- Add-on modules for scheduling, expenses, and time-off
Where Log My Business wins
- Approvals AND locking are free — Clockify needs Standard+ for both
- Real invoicing, CRM, and tasks, not a tracker with add-ons
- No laddering the basics across five tiers
- One connected platform, one bill
QuickBooks Time
No free tier
Time that feeds QuickBooks payroll
Premium $20/mo base + $10/user; Elite $40/mo base + $12/user; no free tier
Free: None — 14-day trial, and a QuickBooks subscription is effectively required
Genuinely great at
- Deepest native payroll and accounting sync in the segment
- GPS, geofencing, and a mobile crew time clock
- Scheduling and shift management bundled in
Where Log My Business wins
- No base fee plus per-user tax — a flat $7.99/user/mo
- Full value without a second QuickBooks subscription
- Projects, tasks, invoicing, and CRM, not just time + payroll
- A genuinely free tier for the whole team
Also worth knowing
Hubstaff adds screenshots and GPS but gates approvals to its $10 Team plan (2-seat minimum).
When I Work and Deputy are shift schedulers — time tracking is a paid add-on, and Deputy
enforces a $30/mo minimum spend. All of them still leave invoicing and CRM to other tools.